Sir Pizza

Key Biscayne institution serving square-cut, thin-crust pies with toppings pushed all the way to the edge, exactly as it has for decades. Order the ranch on the side — that is how the island eats it. No slices, whole pies only.

What to order

• Cheese pizza with a side of ranch
• Veggie Feast pizza

Good for

Know before you go

• Long-running island pizzeria — crust sits between thin and Sicilian
• No pizza by the slice; whole pies only
• The small pie is plenty for two
• Ranch on the side is a paid add-on but it's the local move

More like this

♥ ✓

Cioppino

★ 4.5 (2.9k)

Key Biscayne

italian pastaseafood

♥ ✓

Luma

★ 4.6 (23)

Key Biscayne

italian pasta

♥ ✓

IL Bolognese

★ 4.8 (13.2k)

Miami Beach $$

italian

♥ ✓

Il Lago Trattoria

★ 4.9 (13.1k)

Doral

italian pasta

♥ ✓

Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza – Coconut Grove

★ 4.9 (12.9k)

Michelin

Coconut Grove $$ Since 2014

italian pizza

♥ ✓

Hosteria Romana

★ 4.7 (11.5k)

Miami Beach · Española Way $$

italian pasta